Head-to-head
Pet Food Comparisons: Brand vs Brand
12 side-by-side comparisons between foods that shoppers actually choose between. Each one is scored on the same 6 weighted dimensions, with the differences that matter explained rather than just tabulated.
Dog food comparisons
Orijen Original vs Blue Buffalo Wilderness
91 vs 85
dry · All life stages
Currently ahead: Orijen (91/100)
Taste of the Wild vs Blue Buffalo Wilderness
83 vs 85
dry · Adult maintenance
Currently ahead: Blue Buffalo (85/100)
Hill's Science Diet Adult vs Purina Pro Plan Savor
84 vs 80
dry · Adult maintenance
Currently ahead: Hill's Pet Nutrition (84/100)
Hill's Science Diet Puppy vs Purina Pro Plan Puppy
85 vs 79
dry · Puppy / growth
Currently ahead: Hill's Pet Nutrition (85/100)
Hill's Senior Vitality vs Blue Buffalo Senior
82 vs 80
dry · Senior (7+)
Currently ahead: Hill's Pet Nutrition (82/100)
Hill's Sensitive Stomach vs Purina Pro Plan Sensitive
80 vs 83
dry · Adult maintenance
Currently ahead: Purina Pro Plan (83/100)
Blue Buffalo Homestyle vs Merrick Texas Beef
79 vs 78
wet · Adult maintenance
Currently ahead: Blue Buffalo (79/100)
Cat food comparisons
Orijen Six Fish vs Wellness Complete Health
91 vs 85
dry · All life stages
Currently ahead: Orijen (91/100)
Hill's Indoor vs Royal Canin Indoor
83 vs 78
dry · Adult maintenance
Currently ahead: Hill's Pet Nutrition (83/100)
Hill's Kitten vs Purina Pro Plan Kitten
84 vs 80
dry · Kitten / growth
Currently ahead: Hill's Pet Nutrition (84/100)
Hill's Senior Vitality vs Purina Prime Plus
82 vs 79
dry · Senior (7+)
Currently ahead: Hill's Pet Nutrition (82/100)
Wellness Pate vs Fancy Feast Classic Pate
78 vs 75
wet · Adult maintenance
Currently ahead: Wellness Pet Food (78/100)